Saving the day

When you think about it, the idea of “saving” your work, is quite a strange one.

In the real world (you know, that annoying place where ctrl+F doesn’t work when you’ve lost your keys), you never have to “save”. If you pick up a pad of paper and write something down, you don’t have to then do anything to keep it. It’s written down; it’s permanent. You just put the paper in a drawer and next time you open the drawer, it’s still there.

On a computer, the equivalent action (Pressing File => New) doesn’t keep your writing, unless you “save” your “changes”. Both of these are strange concepts. When I take a blank sheet of paper and write on it, I don’t consider that a “change” to the blank paper, I consider that “my angry letter to the newspaper” or “my shopping list”.

Similarly, when picking options, in real life, I just set my oven to 200ºC and walk away. I don’t have to click “Apply” to change it from 180.


We’ve become so used to saving now (or at least, I have. My parents haven’t and regularly wonder where their things have gone) that we do it without thinking.

But saving is a faff. Over the course of my life, I’ve lost a huge amount of work because someone, once, years ago, made the decision that after spending all day typing a document, I probably don’t want to keep it. On the computer, saving is an after thought. The alert box that pops up when you leave a document says (I’m paraphrasing, but if you read between the lines it sort of says this), “Oh, by the way, you didn’t want to keep this did you? I’ll just chuck it out, shall I?”.

There are a couple of weird things here. The concept of “saving” is an abstraction, added on top of the computer. After all, when you type a character onto the screen, the computer receives that character and stores it in a temporary place. This is probably RAM, but why not put it straight to a permanent place? Some applications, depending on what they do, even keep temporary copies of the file on the actual hard drive, so when you leave the application without saving they then have to delete the records of the file you’ve been working on. Since Office 2003, auto-save writes a copy of the file you’re working on to a temp folder every few minutes, but still assumes that keeping that file is the exception, rather than standard thing to want.

That’s bizarre.  I’m much more likely to want to keep what I’ve done than throw it away. But as far as the computer is concerned, saving is the odd thin;, the change from the standard workflow. Surely it would make more sense to save by default, and I’d have to specifically say “please throw this away”. In much the same way that once I’ve written a page of text by hand, I  have to chose to screw it up and through it in a bin.

Some applications, of course, prompt you to create a file before you start working. When you open Adobe InDesign, for example, you have to chose whether to create a new Document, Template or Book. In typical Adobe form, you need to go on a course before you can work out what it is you want to do. What’s the difference  between a document and a book? If I want to make a three page flyer is that a book? I don’t know. It’s impossible to tell without going on a course.

And even with InDesign, where I begin by creating a file and naming it, once I’ve done making my changes and editing it, InDesign pops up with a box saying, “oh, you want to save now, do you?” as if that isn’t the expected behaviour. While this is better, it still isn’t automatically saving what I’m doing, which is the most likely thing I’m going to want to do. WHY DOES MY COMPUTER SEEM TO THINK I’M WEIRD FOR WANTING TO KEEP MY WORK?

Thankfully, online, this seems to be beginning to change now. Google Docs automatically saves my work as I type. It’s almost like using paper. Increasingly, web applications initiate actions once I chose the option, rather than having to click “apply”. On the iPad, all the options come on when you press them. There is no concept of “Apply”, “OK” or “Cancel” on option screens.

But the idea of “saving” is difficult to shake. In Google Docs, I keep wanting to click save, and am momentarily confused when there is no “save” button. Strangely, over the last twenty years or so of  computer usage, we’ve managed to train people to think “saving” is a special activity.

Maybe I’m being unreasonable about this (I am); after all, we’re all used to saving now, and I almost never lose work (despite the odd power cut). But I’m reminded of a quote from George Bernard Shaw:

The reasonable man adapts himself to the world; the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.

Once we stop being reasonable about saving and start building standard systems where you don’t chose to save but chose to throw away, we won’t missing the little floppy disc icon in the top left hand corner. Or, as ten year old’s today must think of it, the weird square thing that old people used to use when there were dinosaurs around.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s